Season Regulars 4

1. 

   Don Cheadle

   Maurice 'Mo' Monroe

2. 

   Andrew Rannells

   Blair Pfaff

3. 

   Regina Hall

   Dawn Darcy

4. 

   Paul Scheer

   Keith Shankar

Guest Stars 17

1. 

   Casey Wilson

   Tiffany 'Tiff' Georgina

2. 

   Jim Meskimen

   Host of "America's Most Unsolved Crimes"

3. Kavan Reece

   Reenactment Blair

4. 

   Jennifer K. Lee

   Reenactment Dawn

5. Tim McKernan

   Reenactment Keith

6. 

   Bob Rumnock

   Reenactment Jammer

7. 

   Mary-Beth Manning

   Roxanne

8. 

   Patrick Fabian

   Governor Putnam

9. 

   Ken Marino

   Larry Leighman / Lenny Leighman

10. 

    Janelle James

    Joyce

11. Mike Kalinowski

    Leighman Brothers Double

12. Andrew Carrillo

    Butler

13. 

    Tuc Watkins

    Congressman Roger Harris

14. 

    Horatio Sanz

    Wayne Lapotka

15. 

    Deanna Cheng

    Pamela

16. 

    Yassir Lester

    Yassir X

17. 

    Blair Beeken

    Karen

Crew 4