Tommy Dawkins was in the woods celebrating the start of his senior year, when he was attacked by a werewolf. He became a Werewolf and seeks help from a unpopular student, Merton J. Dingle.

The Bookmobile rolls into town, and the librarian that runs this bookmobile strolls into cities, and turns patrons into books.

Merton finds a way to enter Tommy's head, and see all what Tommy sees, hear what all Tommy's thoughts were, and the ability to control Tommy's body - The Janitor's Closet. With this new discovery, Merton helps Tommy get Lori to get back together, and when Merton realized that he would use Tommy's werewolf powers to get revenge on a new student in school that has been threatening and bullying Merton, whose name was Bucky. After this defeat, Bucky noticed the secret entrance too and uses Tommy's werewolf body to get back at Merton, and now Merton, Lori, Tommy, and Bucky are in a battle in Tommy's head for control.

Everyone is out to see the new music band, N'Sipid, but they don't know that this new group is aliens sent to Earth to pick up girls and transport them back to their planet. Tommy also wanted to be part of their group, so he must practise dance moves, with the instructions from Dean, his brother. When Merton realizes that Becky has escaped from the house, he knew that the only place she would be is the N'Sipid concert. So, he arrives at the stadium, and he finds Lori and Tommy there. He tries to obtain help from Tommy, but he did not want to help out. Merton had to try to sneak pass the bodyguard, Tim to get backstage, so he disguised himself as a girl. When he was accepted, he reached the room where the group was, and he finds out that they were reptillian creatures. He was captured and trapped in a pod, which would be sent to the Sun. When Tommy and Lori found out what Merton was gone for too long, they decided to search for him. When they found Devin, they knocked him out and

Merton's role-playing game comes to life, as he is transported to another dimension where he must fight a real fire-breathing monster. Afraid, he decided to return to Merton's world and retrieve help from Tommy. The only problem is that Tommy is acting like Gandhi. The monster, who was a Shederack enters their world, and Tommy, and Merton has to destroy it before he destroys Pleasantville, and so it cannot return to Ursula's world and rule it.