Avoiding the signing of his divorce papers, Jack "Gator" Gately realizes that he is ill-prepared to re-enter the dating scene. While getting lucky with one date, her monkey goes "bananas" for Gator.

Gator's perfect new girlfriend has one minor physical flaw. She has a skin tag on her back, and Gator just can't get past it. He enlists Tommy to take drastic measures and slice it off her. Yet when Gator learns that the flap of skin reminds the girl of her dead mother, he tries to stop Tommy but it's too late.