Стандардне сезоне 5

1. 

   Evan Peters

   Jeffrey 'Jeff' Dahmer

2. 

   Ричард Џенкинс

   Lionel Dahmer

3. 

   Molly Ringwald

   Shari Dahmer

4. 

   Michael Learned

   Catherine Dahmer

5. 

   Niecy Nash-Betts

   Glenda Cleveland

Гостујуће звезде 11

1. 

   Michael Beach

   Det. Dennis Murphy

2. 

   Colby French

   Patrick Kennedy

3. 

   Mac Brandt

   Robert Rauth

4. 

   Shaun Brown

   Tracy Edwards

5. 

   Grant Harvey

   Rolf Mueller

6. 

   Ato Blankson-Wood

   Aaron

7. 

   Chris Gann

   Police Officer #1

8. 

   Rhoyle Ivy King

   Don

9. 

   Joshua Edward Moore

   CSI Investigator

10. Mark Reininga

    Young Police Officer

11. 

    Leanne Suter

    On Camera Reporter

Екипа 13