After a theft at Bayside, a former Douglas student becomes a suspect. Meanwhile, Mac and Jamie fall for the same girl and compete with each other to win her attention.

Slater and Aisha try to toughen up the Bayside football team. Meanwhile, Jessie takes Daisy under her wing.

Aisha tries out for the wrestling team. Daisy has a crush on Gil, the new student council VP.

Aisha questions her cultural identity during a Spanish class. Jamie tries to prove he has a talent.

Bayside holds a dance-a-thon; Jessie and Slater pull a prank. Aisha is nervous to dance.

Bayside takes part in the spirit competition. Mac asks Zack for the secret to beating Valley.