After a theft at Bayside, a former Douglas student becomes a suspect. Meanwhile, Mac and Jamie fall for the same girl and compete with each other to win her attention.

DeVante faces consequences after a student says he pushed him. Mac becomes a payphone.

Tensions arise when Lexi and Aisha work a Teen Line event. Slater and Jessie cut class.

Lexi pushes DeVante to audition for a boy band; Jessie encourages Kelly to apply to medical school.