Ten eligible gentlemen selected by a blue-ribbon panel of matchmakers, including a man in search of his unicorn and another seeking his "precious," vie for the heart of Ashlee, a mystery woman whose love story begins with two heartfelt proposals and one life-changing decision.

Ten eligible women selected by a blue-ribbon panel of matchmakers, including a familiar face from "The Bachelor" franchise, vie for the heart of Stephen, a mystery man who is ready to take a leap of faith to find the love of his life.

Ten eligible gentlemen vie for the heart of Raye, a superstar mystery woman who is an actress, entrepreneur, humanitarian, and former First Lady of an island, ready to be the one and only lady for her love at first sight.

Ten eligible women vie for a chance at love with Dr. Buck, a mystery man hoping to find the one who will make his heart skip a beat.

Ten eligible gentlemen vie for the heart of Latoya, a mystery woman who is a practicing attorney, ready to find a man guilty of stealing her heart.

Ten eligible women selected by a blue-ribbon panel of matchmakers vie for the heart of Winston, a mystery entrepreneur and self-made millionaire, ready to take a risk for love and make a proposal of a lifetime.

Ten eligible men vie for a chance at love with Dr. Celine, a mystery woman looking for the one who can mend her broken heart.

Ten eligible women vie for a chance at love with a mystery man who, as a former suitor, captured the heart of America but not that of the mystery woman. Now he returns for a second shot at love.

Nine eligible gentlemen vie for the heart of a mystery woman looking for a man that is the perfect mix of Mr. Rogers and Christian Grey. Over the course of the evening, only two lucky gentlemen will have the opportunity to make a proposal of a lifetime.