The celebrity panel of Kal Penn, Adam Rodriguez, Nikki Glaser, and Justin Long is faced with finding a famous bowtie designer who is a janitor by day, a successful Marine who invited Mila Kunis as his date to the Marine Corps Ball, the inventor of "joggling" (juggling while running), and someone that was rescued by Harrison Ford.

Celebrity guest panel is presented with the only person in the world to bike to the South Pole, the "Doggy Designer to the Star," and Usher's choreographer.

Oliver Hudson, Candace Cameron Bure, Kal Penn, and Ross Matthews make up the celebrity panel, and are presented with a variety of participants with interesting stories, from a drumming prodigy to a Miss America coach and an original model on The Price is Right.

Theresa Caputo, Kal Penn, Denise Richards, and Matt McGorry make up the celebrity panel and are presented with a variety of participants with interesting stories, from the first female African-American airline captain to the creator of Zumba and a professional dead guy.