Chidi bliver træt af at bruge så meget tid på at undervise Eleanor. Tahani spionerer og er ikke glad for det, hun opdager. Michael sætter nabolaget i karantæne.

Eleanor, Jason, Chidi og Tahani skændes om, hvilke to af dem skal tage til Det Dårlige Sted. Eleanor når til en chokerende erkendelse om sit paradis.

Having had their memories erased by ambitious master architect Michael, Eleanor, Chidi, Tahani and Jason again settle into the Good Place, unaware of what has previously transpired...except that Eleanor discovers the one clue she had left for herself and attempts to piece things together.