In 2012, 21-year-old Mickey Shunick is missing after a night out in Lafayette, LA. Her family is terrified and mobilizes the local community to help search for her. Police are unable to find any trace of the Louisiana student -- until they spot her on surveillance video.

In September 2012, University of Florida freshman Christian Aguilar mysteriously vanishes from campus. His girlfriend, father and best friend are in turmoil. Police have nowhere to turn -- until a CCTV recording turns the case in a shocking new direction.