Now that Becky has finally put all her high school insecurities behind, she returns to her alma mater as a guidance counselor. However, she soon finds that her high school nemesis, Lisa, is a teacher in the school as well. Soon, Becky finds herself competing with Lisa for the eye of Tim the attractive Spanish teacher, among other things.

A new substitute Spanish sub (Ashton Kutcher) causes a stir when he threatens Tim's position as Spanish teacher.

When Becky finds herself at the bottom of the list of most attractive teachers at a student's gossip blog, she fakes disinterest but secretly tries to move up the rankings.

A shortsighted Bruce assigns Becky, who is the least creative faculty member on campus, to direct the school's high school musical.