Randy must go with Howard to CluckFest under the threat of Bash Johnson. This won't be easy for Randy since he is afraid of chickens. Meanwhile, Hannibal McFist and Willem Viceroy III unleash a fear-pooping robotic rhinoceros called the Rhinosaurus that forces everyone to confront their worst fear as part of their plot to find the Ninja's greatest fear and take advantage of it.

Randy, Howard, and all the boys at Norrisville High are entranced by the new girl in school named Amanda Levay. Little do they know that she's the Sorceress (voiced by Jennifer Tilly), the Sorcerer's long lost love in disguise where she has plans to free the Sorcerer.

Coach Green brings back an old Norrisville High tradition, Prank Day.

During "Ninja Day" McFist schemes to steal the spotlight by introducing a new hero - Himself.