Miley agrees to go steady with Jake again, but she worries that all of the times she complained about Jake might have turned Robby against the young man. When she learns that Robby dislikes Jesse, a troublemaking teen guitarist in Hannah's band, Miley hatches a plan to make Jake look great.

Miley's scheme to get Jake back into Robby's good graces works out beautifully and she believes that they are headed for a happy ending. Things change, however, when Miley realizes that Robby misjudged Jesse's true nature and she now finds herself drawn to the handsome musician.