While Katie sets up for her big charity event, she is stunned to find that Dan has yet again disappeared. This time around, Dan travels back to the year 1995 in order to help a woman on a blind date, but when Livia arrives to assist Dan with his mission she seems more interested in Dan's relationship with Katie.

While alone with Zach Dan gets one of his headaches. In the past Dan finds himself digging into the life of Dylan McCleen, an Army Ranger who stole money for a good reason. Katie is questioned about a robbery that happened the night of her big party.

Dan goes back to help two brothers who have been abused by their father. Jack gets suspicious of Dan and thinks he might be gambling again. While in the past Dan and Livia overhear a conversation between Jack and Katie.

In the 1990s Dan finds himself tracking a serial kidnapper. When Katie gets called into Zack's school, she wonders how much Dan's traveling is affecting him. Jack is beginning to believe Dan is traveling in time. This episode is the first part, the conclusion is Blowback

On Christmas Eve the newspaper is hit by layoffs and Dan's new mission involves saving it. Meanwhile, Katie deals with the aftermath of Aeden's home invasion, and Jack and Theresa get startling news.

While Dan struggles to save a mother and child in the past, Katie has to deal with her well-meaning sister who wants to help, just as Zack disappears.