When Nikki suddenly goes missing, MPU bands together and discovers that Raina, a criminal who Nikki put away, has escaped and is out for vengeance.

An accomplished playwright is kidnapped prior to a local theatre's grand reopening. MPU discovers that the victim and her partner had received a video threat ordering them to shut down the troubled theater, which had previously been severely damaged in a fire decades earlier killing 87, or the playwright will be burned to death. Meanwhile, Jason asks Wayne to track down who's the father of Sidney's baby.