Three women residents of the New England town of Eastwick each make a wish on a coin, summoning a mysterious man named Darryl Van Horne into their town. Strange things occur upon his arrival and local historian Bun predicts ominous events in the horizon.

The ladies agree never to reveal what they did to Jamie. Joanna tries to help Penny find closure and sparks fly between Kat and her new neighbor, a single father with a dark secret.