Mae changes her mind about leaving New York; Carlos has his hands full with a case of attempted murder; Laura starts her new job; Whitney struggles with planning her wedding; Damian's helps someone else's fate, but worries about his own; and Steven new job could possibly turn his entire life around.

While Whitney plans her wedding, the streets of New York are threaten by the Puncher, a rogue criminal who punches, what seems to be, total strangers and runs. Carlos and Mae go on a double date to a karaoke bar with Damian and Regina, and Damian realizes Maes that she is the girl who is researched. Meanwhile Laura wonders whether her friendship with Whitney can survive telling her the truth about Roy, her fiancé; and Caseman meets with his son, Max, and ex-wife and learns that there are more complications to his new life than he originally thought.

Damian decide to proposes to Regina but still won’t be honest about his criminal past. Steven finally gets a chance to spend quality time with his son, but when Whitney offers him the job of a lifetime, it forces him to reassess his priorities. During the meantime, Laura receives a promotion with some big strings attached.

Ray hires Laura and Caseman to decorate his new office space, and while working together, they figure out that they have chemistry. However, Ray learns that Caseman means more to Whitney than he originally thought. Meanwhile Damian goes to work for Ray and uses his boss' name to pull a favor for Carlos, who lands a new job, and Mae finds out about a woman who may be her mother while babysitting for Laura and Caseman.