When Overlord enlists the family to look for an object he misplaced one year ago, he leads the Underwoods to recount the first day he arrived at their home. In the flashbacks, Jim tries to impress his parents at dinner.

Overlord's carelessness puts the family in danger, leading to the ultimate test of his moral compass. Meanwhile, Willow tries to post the perfect verified social media post and Weaver attempts to finally put his stories on film.