Horstachio of a Different Color: A new Horstachio comes along, and he enters the Horastachio Competition that Hudson has won four years in a row. Will his winning streak die down, now that a new Horastachio is in town?

Paulie and Fergy ask the short-term memory Ella Elephanilla to the Dance of Romance, unbeknownst to each other. Can either ONE of them go to the dance with Ella, and why is Franklin helping both of them with the situation?

Professor Pester and his henchmen disguise themselves as a female horstachio in order to trap Hudson. Hudson immediately falls in love with the new horstachio, but insists on showing her everything about him and his life. Pester will need to create a love greater than Hudson's love for himself if he hopes to capture him.

It's time for the Annual Beach Blanket Blowout Bash, but there is a volcano erupting near it and Les Galagoogoo is the only one who knows about it, and no one understands him! Can he save everyone, and at least have everyone know about it?

When Franklin saves Hudson's life, he's been hailed as a famous hero, but what happens when the modest Fizzlybear's fame soon eclipses Hudson's?

Fergy and Paulie bake pie for their friends, but the tasty raisins in the pie have a nasty side-effect, they cause a Piñata to behave in an opposite manner to their normal personality. Can Fergy and Paulie reverse the effects before the garden goes crazy?

When Ella Elephanilla calls reporter Pecky Pudgeon about a threatening letter, he comes to her home -- only to find her missing. This leads him on the trail of mystery as one by one, all his piñata acquaintances vanish. In the end, he finds and rescues Ella – and learns the astonishing secret behind the mystery.

When Paulie Pretztail discovers that Party Central has classified him as a Squazzil his self-image shatters. He embraces his ‘true’ heritage and moves in with his kin... but then (like all visiting relatives) Paulie proceeds to drive his new Squazzil family nuts! Can Fergy prove to Paulie that he really is a Pretztail before the Squazzils do their annoying new family member in?

Teddington insults a passing Goobaa, which gets its revenge by framing Teddy for vandalism. Can Teddy prove his innocence before the other Piñatas run him out of town—or worse?

Fergy sets up a service in which Piñatas can unload their secrets on Ella, since she always forgets what she is told; however, she begins to remember them.

The Big Boss decides to hold elections for Langston's position as "Commander Guy", and Hudson emerges as the frontrunner

Paulie and Fergy decide to "retire" so that they will no longer have to worry about Langston. The Bonboon sells them land in a new "retirement paradise" called "Amazing Acres". But when our guys arrive, they discover that "Amazing Acres" is located in the frozen arctic tundra.

Fergy and the gang have made it to the Finals of the Pinata Island Soccer tournament – despite having Shirley Shelleybelly (snail) on their team. But when a gang of thuggish fans kidnaps the opposing team and takes their place, it looks like certain doom for our favorite piñata team!

Fergy and Paulie enter a cooking contest, facing Shirley Shellybean and Professor Pester for a lifetime supply of candy.

Hudson learns from Dr. Quackberry that he has a parasite that is eating up all of his candy.

Hudson's angry rant against several Sweetooth workers gets recorded onto his talking doll by accident, offending the other Piñatas.

Professor Pester's plan to seize candy involves luring a sleepwalking Ella to his lair, and Fergy and Paulie must do what they can to stop it.