This episode guest starred Shelly Faberes as Vanessa Peekskill, the great-great granddaughter of the Captain's lost love. She comes to Gull Cottage to find more information on their romance that she has discovered in letters that Captain Gregg had written to her ancestor. The Captain is immediately enchanted by Vanessa and insists that she stay as long as she wishes and have a free run of the house, including the sea chest which has always been off limits. Carolyn finds herself growing more and more jealous over Vanessa and the attention the Captain pays to her and she begins to wonder if maybe they should move and leave Vanessa and the Captain alone.