The members of JONAS try their hand at acting in a school production of the Three Musketeers. Joe then becomes jealous after finding out that Van Dyke Tosh, who fills in for Joe due to stage fright, is Stella's love interest.

A teacher lets Joe slide on an accident with a fire alarm, but gives his friend Abby detention for the same mistake. Joe then attempts to get detention which he succeeds, and tries to apologize to Abby with Nick and Kevin's help. Meanwhile, Stella struggles with her grade in P.E. class, and tries to make sewing a sport.