Discuss Black Panther
Discuss → Movies → Black Panther → General
Obligatory Re-Ranking of the top MCU movies
posted by spreerod1538STAFFMOD on February 16, 2018 at 2:49 PM
Tier 1 (Great, can watch over an over):
- 1. Captain America: The Winter Soldier
- 2. Guardians of the Galaxy Volume 1
- 3. The Avengers
- 4. Captain America: Civil War
- 5. Black Panther
- 6. Thor Ragnarok
- 7. Guardians of the Galaxy Volume 2
Tier 2 (very good):
- 8. Spider-man Homecoming
- 9. Iron Man
- 10. Ant Man
Tier 3 (still good):
- 11. Avengers Age of Ultron
- 12. Dr. Strange
- 13. Thor
- 14. Captain America: The First Avenger
Tier 4 (mediocre to bad):
- 15. The Incredible Hulk
- 16. Iron Man 3
- 17. Iron Man 2
- 18. Thor 2
Anyone else want to share? The tier 1 keeps getting bigger and bigger for me.
Reply by spreerod1538
on February 17, 2018 at 2:56 PM
lol they're my rankings.. you can rank whatever movies you want. I didn't love Dr. Strange, therefore it's in tier 3. I don't think it's that hard to comprehend.
Reply by jomarthecat
on February 17, 2018 at 5:21 PM
I would put BP in tier 4. Maybe 3. It was mostly boring. And annoying.
Reply by Horus Mazinga
on February 18, 2018 at 2:47 AM
Close to my ranking. My changes are in bold
Tier 1 (Great, can watch over an over):
Tier 2 (very good):
Tier 3 (still good):
Tier 4 (mediocre to bad):
Sorry but BP disappointed me. It didn't suck but was a let down. Most of the fights sucked and movie turned boring midway. Whoever edited the previews should have directed the movie. Previews were incredible. Movie was meh. 5.5/10
Reply by drjekel_mrhyde
on February 18, 2018 at 3:49 PM
No BvS.............oops wrong thread.
/I kid
Reply by spreerod1538
on February 19, 2018 at 9:58 AM
Fair enough! I really liked the story. The fight scenes were not great though. I've had arguments with my friends over Thor Ragnarok actually. I felt the ending sequence in that movie had the best action scene of any of the marvel movies, especially set to Led Zeppelin.
I see you dislike the Avengers movies.. What don't you like about the first one? I completely understand the 2nd one being in tier 4 though.
Reply by Horus Mazinga
on February 19, 2018 at 3:10 PM
The fundamental story was cool but I thought it suffered greatly in the details and the directing. I was mostly enjoying it up till around Claw biting it and, of course, the poor fights featuring BP. Everyone did a good job acting wise. I probably had much too high expectations.
Thor 3 might have had too many jokes but it was beautifully directed and a decent adaptation of the Ragnarok story line (nothing could ever accurately capture Simonson's run). Fantastic action. I'd edit out 30% of the jokes but I don't know which ones since I liked most all of them.
I don't hate the first Avengers. It would be a tier higher except for its pasted-on ending. A2, on the other hand, was terrible. I loved the Iron Man vs Hulk fight (a better fight than anything in BP) but that is nearly all.