Cast 38

1. 

   Selma Blair

   Vi

2. 

   Leo Fitzpatrick

   Marcus

3. 

   Robert Wisdom

   Mr. Scott

4. 

   Maria Christina Thayer

   Ami

5. 

   Angela Goethals

   Elli

6. Devorah Rose

   Lucy

7. Nancy Anne Ridder

   Joyce

8. 

   Steve Rosen

   Ethan

9. 

   Aleksa Palladino

   Catherine

10. 

    Mary Lynn Rajskub

    Melinda

11. 

    Tina Holmes

    Sue

12. 

    Paul Giamatti

    Toby Oxman

13. 

    Mike Schank

    Mike the Cameraman

14. 

    Xander Berkeley

    Mr. DeMarco

15. 

    Mark Webber

    Scooby Livingston

16. 

    John Goodman

    Marty Livingston

17. 

    Julie Hagerty

    Fern Livingston

18. Jonathan Osser

    Mikey Livingston

19. 

    Noah Fleiss

    Brady Livingston

20. 

    Lupe Ontiveros

    Consuelo

21. Jessica Dunphy

    Cheryl

22. Nick Maltes

    Esposito

23. 

    Steve Railsback

    Mr. Kirk

24. 

    Crista Moore

    Elizabeth St. Clair

25. 

    Franka Potente

    Toby's Editor

26. Andrew Marantz

    Stanley

27. 

    Conan O'Brien

    Himself

28. 

    Frederick B. Owens

    Football Coach

29. Barry Jordan

    Dr. Barry Jordan

30. Robin Goodman

    Dr. Robin Goodman

31. Eric Nieves

    Dave

32. 

    Marisa Redanty

    Onlooker #1

33. 

    Ilana Levine

    Onlooker #2

34. 

    Jennifer Elise Cox

    Musical Theatre Actress (uncredited)

35. 

    Pat Kiernan

    TV News Announcer (voice) (uncredited)

36. Gina Priano

    Student (uncredited)

37. Tom Schimmels

    Man in Toby's Apartment (uncredited)

38. 

    Jim Titus

    Football Player (uncredited)

Troupe 11