Den lille by Cherry Falls er et fredeligt sted, lige indtil en psykotisk seriemorder begynder at finde sine ofre blandt byens unge. Først efter at en tredje teenager er fundet brutalt myrdet, begynder morderens dagsorden at dæmre: Alle de myrdede er jomfruer! Mens byens unge hurtigt finder ud af, at der kun er ét at foretage sig, hvis de skal undgå at komme på dødslisten, tager sheriffens datter Jody, der stadig er jomfru, sagen i egen hånd. I mere end én forstand. Brittany Murphy (Sidewalks of New York) ses som sheriffens datter, Jody, mens hendes far spilles af Michael Biehn (The Art of War). Desuden medvirker Jay Mohr (Pay It Forward) i denne film, der fra start til slut er propfyldt med både humor og horror.

Francis and Blake Falls are Siamese twins who live in a neat little room in a rundown hotel. While sharing some organs, Blake is always fit and Francis is very sickly. Into their world comes a young lady, who turns their world upside down. She gets involved with Blake, and convinces the two to attend a Halloween party, where they can pass themselves off as wearing a costume. Eventually Francis becomes really ill, and they have to be separated. They then face the physical and mental strains that come from their proposed separation.